The Unforgotten is a fitting title for Laura Powell ’s mystery with two timelines—one set in 1956 and the other about 50 years later—and whose characters are consumed by secrets. Secret feelings. Secret love affairs. Secret obsessions. Secret details about a slew of murders at the hand of the ‘Cornish Clever’ in the coastal English village of St. Steele. While these secrets many have remained buried for half a century, they were never forgotten.
Mary was but 15 years old during the summer of the killings, and she has felt the weight of the secrets surrounding the events most of her life. They affected her relationships then and in the present. When the story of the Cornish Cleaver resurfaces in the media, Mary is in her sixties. She starts to unravel. The advice of a landlady in a neighborhood pub hits close to home: “If I’ve learned one thing from spending half my life listening to people from behind this bar, it’s that lies are worse than cancer. Trust me. They eat you up and poison you, so you either let them rest for good or you cut them out.” And so, Mary starts a pursuit to rid herself of the secrets she’s been harbouring, for so long, and find out the truth once and for all.
For me, the pleasure in reading this story was not trying to figure out who the true culprit was (which was pleasurable, mind you), but seeing how guilt, fear, and love rule the characters’ decision-making. While the roiling tension in the final chapters keeps you reading until the final line, the palpable sentiments of Mary, Betty, and John are the true driving force of the story.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster Canada and Gallery Books for providing me with an advanced reader’s copy of The Unforgotten in exchange for an honest book review. Hardcopies hit Canadian and American bookshelves on February 6, 2018.