A Family Unravels: My October by Claire Holden Rothman


            My October by Claire Holden Rothman
            Penguin Canada, 2014.
            352 pages, $22.95

Claire Holden Rothman’s sophomore novel, My October, has received a whirlwind of merited attention. It was longlisted for the Scotiabank Giller Prize and nominated for the Governor General’s Award for Fiction. Although the novel examines how the October Crisis of 1970 still resonates in the lives of the Québécois, its main focus explores how cultural identity can impact relationships. The story revolves around three unravelling protagonists: venerated novelist and nationalist Luc Lévesque, his dejected wife Hannah, and their troubled teenage son Hugo. They all struggle to connect with each other while their family comes undone.

Luc Lévesque walks away from the burdens of family life in October 2001. He moves into the run-down, wedge house that figures prominently in Gabrielle Roy’s French-Canadian classic—Bonheur d’occasion (The Tin Flute). Those of us who cherish that beloved novel may find “the wooden structure tapering at one end like a boat’s hull, ‘twisted, as if to brace itself against life’s shocks’” to be a fitting home for Luc. He’s a washed-up man, having a mid-life crisis, heading off course at alarming speed.

Worries plague Hannah Lévesque during this tense autumn. Being the daughter of Alfred Stein—viewed by separatists as an infamous anglophone prosecutor during the October Crisis—has never been easy. The father-daughter relationship becomes more difficult after Stein suffers a stroke that renders him unable to speak. While Hannah is caring for her father, her disgruntled husband moves out. It becomes impossible for her to concentrate on her work or routine tasks. Our hearts ache when she worries about Hugo, who “was a black hole, singular and unknowable, into which she was pouring her darkest, most inarticulate fears.”

Hugo causes a stir after being suspended for carrying a handgun to school. The rebellious teen rejects his overbearing, famous father. In fact, he renounces Luc’s native tongue, culture, and beliefs by speaking English and adopting Hannah’s maiden name. Hugo manifests a desperate need to learn about past events that divided his father and maternal grandfather. Alongside Hugo, we revisit the role of the separatist terrorist group Front de libération du Québec (FLQ) in the 1970 kidnapping of British diplomat James Cross.

Certain plot elements in this family saga are hard to swallow, the most obvious being the improbability of Luc—a dur de dur separatist—marrying an anglophone woman who happens to be the daughter of the man responsible for prosecuting his friends. Other weak plot elements figure in the over-the-top epilogue, which may disappoint readers. Perhaps the author tried to tackle too many topics to create a tangible tension. Still, we can overlook such details (especially if we skip the epilogue) because Claire Holden Rothman creates a convincing voice for the Québécois. She captures the malaise of Francophone characters coping in a post-referendum and post-9/11 time with astute accuracy.

Like the much-loved characters in Bonheur d’occasion, Luc, Hannah, and Hugo face solitude and despair. Readers will surely brace themselves amid the turbulence to find out how the Lévesque family pull through—or apart.


7 thoughts on “A Family Unravels: My October by Claire Holden Rothman

  1. I love family dramas anchored by historical events. Historical Canadian events even better! I am curious now how the family comes through in the end. Nice review- I’ve been curious about this book.

  2. I’m chewing my cheek ever so gently. I’m crazy about history and so very fond of well done historical fiction, but I suspect that knowing jack shit about any Quebecois crisis of 1970 (I know about the general argument and issues and fighting and bitterness because it features big in one of my best ‘jokes’ I pulled off in Eastern Europe). Wait. Where was I? Oh. I’m pretty sure a whole lot of the power of this book would be deflated for me.

    I should probably delete all of the above, but now that I’ve written it, you can suffer it, too. Consider it a bonding moment. 🙂

  3. Carole Besharah says:

    Bwhaha. Cris you kill me. your snark and sass always put a smile to me face. Don’t delete your comments. Ever. They are too much fun.

    You really do not need to know anything about the October Crisis of 1970 to appreciate this book. The author does a great job of explaining it through the eyes of a teenager who knows little about it. Also, many younger Canadians (especially English ones living outside of Quebec) also know nothing about that event.

    It was a defining moment for Canadians –for the Quebecois in particular. The author did an excellent job of how the crisis still resonates in that unique part of Canada today. That’s why I loved it so much.

  4. Joelle Ethier says:

    Sounds like a great read… Will definitely put it on my list (despite the links with Bonheur d’Occasion, which was not a favorite).

    • Carole Besharah says:

      WHAT!!?? You did NOT like Bonheur d’occasion? How is that even possible? I think it’s my favourite French-Canadian novel.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s